Electric analogue computer



P 9, 1952 s. BECKWITH ET AI; 2,609,988

ELECTRIC ANALOGUE COMPUTER Filed March 17, 1950 2 SHEET$--SHEET 1 m4 5 Q5 m, 9 m. 96%

AMPE/PES Sept. 9, 1952 s. BECKWITH ET AL 2,609,988

ELECTRIC ANALOGUE COMPUTER Filed March 17, 1950 2 SHEETSSHEET 2 VOL 725 Patented Sept. 9, 1952 ELECTRIC ANALOGUE COMPUTER Sterling Beckwith, Wauwatosa, and Eldo C. Koenig', Waukesha, Wis., assignors to Allis- Chalmers Manufacturing Company, Milwaukee,

Wis.

Application March 17, 1950, Serial No. 150,117

11 Glaims. 1

This invention relates to an electric analogue computer for the solution of problems involving single valued nonlinear parameters as occur in hydraulics, aerodynamics, mechanical springs, and magnetic circuits. This invention relates more particularly to means and methods involved in an electric analogue circuit usable for determining the saturation characteristics of the magnetic circuit of a salient pole dynamoelectric machine. v

The electric analogue circuit comprises adjustable linear and nonlinear resistance elements and sources of variable electromotive force so connected in mesh as to represent the magnetic circuit of a salient pole dynamoelectric machine. The values of the resistance elements and. voltages are such as to correspond to known or desired values of the reluctance and magnetomotive force components in the magnetic circuit. The resulting values of the currents in and the voltages across the resistance elements in the electric circuit are thus representative, respectively, of the values of flux and magnetomotive force across corresponding components of the magnetic circuit of the dynamoelectric machine.

The magnetic circuit of a salient pole dynamoelectric machine comprises magnetic material having a nonlinear saturation characteristic, which characteristic heretofore has been an obstacle in accurately representing the magnetic material in an electric circuit.

-This'disadvantage is obviated by the invention described herein, which provides that nonlinear reluctances of the magnetic material be represented by nonlinear resistance elements each comprising a phototube connected in parallel with a linear resistance element.

It is therefore an object of the invention to provide an electric analogue computer for use in the solution of certain problems involving single valued functions of nonlinear parameters.

Another object of the invention is to provide a magnetic saturation analyzer for determining the saturation characteristics of a magnetic circuit.

Another object of the invention is to provide an electric analogue circuit in which each element has a conductivity characteristic similar to the permeability characteristic of a corresponding portionof the material of the magnetic circuit.

Another object of the invention is to provide a magnetic saturation analyzer for determining saturation characteristics of a dynamoelectric machine for open circuit and various power factor operating conditions thereof.

Other objects and advantages will be apparent from a consideration of the following description taken in connection with the accompanying drawing, in which:

Fig. 1 diagrammatically illustrates the circuit of the analogue computer including phototubes and a plurality of sources of unidirectional voltages, and the connection of the lamps providing illumination for the phototubes;

Fig. 2 diagrammatically illustrates a source of power supplying voltages for the current of Fig. 1;

Fig. 3 is an end view of the portion of the dynamoelectric machine including the armature teeth, air gap and pole piece forming the magnetic circuit represented by the electric analogue of Fig. 1;

Fig. 4 is a graph of the magnetic saturation characteristics of a cube of magnetic material and of the volt ampere characteristic of a phototube shown in Fig. 1;

Fig. 5 shows an alternative means of connecting sources of unidirectional voltages in the circuit of Fig. 1; and

Fig. 6 shows an adjustable shutter for a phototube of Fig. 1.

Referring more particularly to Fig. 3 of the drawing, numeral 1 designates a pole pitch portion of the armature core of a dynamoelectric machine, which may have any number of winding slots but which is shown having six teeth 9 to H and six slots 8 per pole pitch, the slots 8 containing windings 15. A field pole [6, having a pole head or pole piece I! with damper windings l8 therein, is provided with a field winding l9. An air gap 20 is formed between the pole piece H and the teeth of the armature core. The armature core 1, pole l6, pole piece I! and the air gap 20 constitute a portion of the magnetic circuit of the dynamoelectric machine which is representative of the other portions of the machine forming similar magnetic circuits.

The magnetic circuit is illustrated as divided by dotted lines into substantially radial segments, each segment including one of the teeth 9 to l4 and corresponding adjacent portions of the air gap and pole piece portions 29 to 34. The dotted lines further subdivide each tooth, from root to tooth tip portion, into circumferential portions 2| to 24.

The magnetic circuit of Fig. 3 extending between the pole and the roots of the armature teeth is represented by the electric circuit of Fig. 1 in which the resistance elements are connected in mesh to represent the corresponding subdivided reluctance portions of the magnetic circuit of the dynamoelectric machine for an open circuit satu- 5 ration condition thereof.

The electric circuit comprises conductors 42, 43

3 and a source of suitable unidirectional voltage which may be a battery or any other suitable known source such as a generator supplying alternating current to an adjustable tap transformer 26 which has its secondary winding 21 connected across the circuit through a suitable rectifier 28. The voltage applied across the circuit is adjusted so that its value corresponds to the predetermined value of the magnetomotive;

force produced by the ampere turns of the field for forcing flux through the air gap, the teeth of the armature and the pole piece for a given noload operating condition of the, machine.

The circuit further comprises linear and non-' linear resistance elements connected in mesh across the winding 21 and rectifier 28. Each nonlinear resistance element comprises a phototube shunted by an adjustable resistor to represent the reluctance of a corresponding portion of the core material. The linearresistanceelements comprise adjustable resistors, representing the reluctance-of portions of the air gap, and resistors 52 representing the transverse. reluctance of the slots ofrthearma-ture core. I

Phototubes -to35and resistor are connected in series with each other through a contact of a, suitablerselector switch 44 to form a series circuit between conductors 42,-43, which circuit, .is designated herein as the first series circuit. Phototubes 35 to 38 and their associated resistors 39 correspond to. portions 2: to 24 respectively of. tooth H.

segment including .tooth H and the adjacent portionSI ofpole piece 11. This portion of the pole," piece is-not saturated and its reluctance I therefore is constant.

shorting switch 5|, and-another nonlinear re-'- sis tahce element comprising a phototube 49 and its -associated, parallel connected, adjustable resistor 39. Phototubel liieand its associatedresistorrepresent the portion'3 of the pole piece adjacent tooth I0, whichlmay becomeqsatulfated and therefore have a nonlinear reluctance, particularly where there are; damper windings IS, in the pole piece.

Another radial segment, including tooth 19,2 and pole piece portion 291s represented by athird seri sycircuit comprising phototubes 55. to. 58 and :their associated resistors; 39, whichrepresent the-portions 2i to 24,;respectively ofutoothuil.v

These phototubes are connected in series between conductors d2, 43 throughselector switch and a shorting switch 6|, an adjustable resistor 00 representingt'ne portionof the ,air gap 20, adjacent tooth 9, phototube 59;.with'its associated parallel connected resistor 39 representing an'adjacent pole tip portion 29 of pole piece I1 which may become saturated, and phototube d9 of the second series circuit. An adjustable resistor 62 is connectedthrough a shortingswitch BBbetWeen conductor 42 landthe connection of resistor with phototube 59. The right half of .the pole pitch:portion of the dynamoelectric machine comprising :radial segments Which-include teeth I2; 13, M and pole piece portions 32, 33,54 is a mirror image'of thelef-t hand half by fourth, fifth-and sixth series circuits havin Adjustable resistor 40 corresponds to the air gap portion of the radial similar elements similarly connected as the first, second, and third series circuits, respectively. The fourth series circuit includes phototubes 65 to 68, and adjustable resistor 10 connected in series between conductors 42, 43. The fifth series circuit includes phototubes 15 to 18, shorting switch 8!, adjustable resistor 80, and phototubes 19 connected between conductors 42, 43. The sixth series circuit includes phototubes Y to 88, shorting switch 9!, adjustable resistor 90,

in series with. a phototube of the first groupof the corresponding series circuit. A third group' oflelementscomprises phototubes 31, 41, 51, 61,

11, 81 anda fourth'group com-prises phototubes 38, d8, .59, 68, 18,.and 88,. each of which is con nected in series with the-corresponding phototubes of the adjacent groups, which phototubes are in corresponding series circuits. f

For interconnectingthe elements of adjacent series circuits to form a mesh circuit, adjustable resistors 52 .are provided ,to represent slot por tionsrbetween the teeth of the armature core. A terminalof one of these resistors 52 is con nected to the juncture of tubes 55, 56, and the other terminal of this resistor is connected through a shorting switch 53 to the juncture oftubes 45,116. Similarly, resistors 52 and associated shorting switches 53 interconnect each adjacent pair of series connected phototubes with the corresponding pair ,of phototubes of the adjacent series circuits, except that shortingswitches.

may be omitted betweenthe first andfourth see ries circuits, as shown in Fig. ,1.-

Adjustable means for -illuminating the phototubes comprise lamps to 99, each of which-is connectedthrough an adjutableresistor l00 to a circuit iill connected to an adjustable voltage.

source such as a battery 102 and a series connected adjustable resistor I03. Lamp 95 supplies illumination for the bias of phototubes of the first group," and lamps 96-, 91, and 98, supply illumination for the phototubes of. the :second,

third, and fourth groups, respectively. Lamp, 99 supplies illumination for phototubes 49, 59,

Means are provided for simultaneouslylvary ing-the illumination-of-all the phototubes-35, 45, 55, 65,15, 85,-of-the first group independently of the illumination-of the phototubes, of {the other groups such as the adjustable resistor I00 connected in series with:lamp 95 for varying, the energization; of lamp-95;} Similarly, the illumination-of all the phototubes oreach of the other groups may be varied simultaneously, inde-.

pendently of that of the othergroups, byradjust supplying'illumination to the group.

merit of the resistor I00 associated with the lamp.

Means 13 are provided. for simultaneously varyage of circuit l0i,- and; therefore, the-voltage across each-of the lamps 95't'o;99,-

Means are .provided for-varying the lillumina tion supplied to each phototube, independently of that supplied to other phototubes, such as a suitable known adjustable shutter I04, comprising relatively movable shutters H6, H1, Fig. 6, disposed between each phototube and the lamp from which it derives its illumination.

In operation of the analyzer for determining the saturation characteristics of the magnetic circuit of a dynamoelectric machine, the resistors are adjusted so that their relative'values are proportional to the known or desired relative values of corresponding reluctances of the magnetic circuit portions which they represent. For example, the reluctance of the root portion 2I of a tooth is less' than the reluctance of an intermediate portion 23 because of tapering of the teeth. Similarly, the reluctance of a tooth tip portion 24, where the slot wedge notch further reduces the cross section, is proportionately greater than the reluctance of other portions of the tooth.

Therefore, the series connected nonlinear resistance elements such as phototubes 35 to 38, are adjusted to provide resistances in the series circuit to correspond to the relative reluctances of the corresponding portions of tooth I I. Similarly, the resistor 40 is adjusted to provide resistance corresponding to the relative reluctance of the air gap portion adjacent tooth I I. The nonlinear resistance element comprising phototube 59 is adjusted to provide a resistance representing the reluctance of the corresponding pole tip portion 29 adjacent tooth 9. The reluctance of this pole tip portion varies with respect to the rest of the pole piece because of the greater saturation thereof. If saturation exists in pole piece portions 3i, 32 they can also be represented by nonlinear resistance elements as are pole piece portions 29 and 34.

In order to adjust a nonlinear resistance element of the electric circuit to provide resistance proportional to the reluctance of the corresponding portion of the magnetic circuit, the nonlinear resistance element comprising a phototube and a. parallel connected resistor must have a conductivity characteristic which corresponds to the permeability characteristic of the magnetic material. Curve I06, Fig. 4, represents the flux versus ampere-turn characteristic or saturation characteristic of a unit cube of the magnetic material of the dynamoelectric machine. Curve I06 may be considered to be obtained by adding the ordinates of an intrinsic linear characteristic I01,

to those of an intrinsic nonlinear characteristic- Curve I09, Fig. 4, represents the ampere-volt characteristic or conductivity characteristic of a phototube such as an R. C. A. type 922 phototube. This characteristic may be considered to be obtained by adding the ordinates of an intrinsic linear characteristic IIO to those of an intrinsic nonlinear characteristic I I I.

Curve I08, the intrinsic nonlinear characteristic of the magnetic material and curve I I I, the intrinsic nonlinear characteristic of the phototube, are caused to coincide, in Fig. 4, by suitable choice of units. Drawn to these units, the saturation characteristic I06 differs from the conductivity characteristic I09 by the difference between their intrinsic linear characteristics, curves I01 and IIO shifting curve I09 by the difference between the ordinates of I01 and H0, will make curve I09 coincide with curve I06. Therefore, the addition of a resistor having a conductivity characteristic determined by the difference betweencurves I0'I and II;0 connected across the ance elements and the voltages impressed on the circuit are properly proportioned to correspond to the components of the magnetic circuit, then readings of the values of currents in the resistance elements indicate the corresponding distribution of flux in the magnetic circuit; readings of voltages across elements indicate the corresponding magnetcmotive force distribution in the magnetic circuit. Current readings are obtained by connecting an ammeter I I5 at different points in the electric circuit. The ammeter is shown connected in series with phototubes 36, 31, by means of one of the jack switches 54 provided between the series connected phototubes. The voltages may be obtained by use of a suitable known voltmeter I I2, preferably a potentiometer type voltmeter which is connected to draw no current from the analogue circuit, shown as connected across phototube 65.

For analyzing the saturation characteristics of a magnetic circuit of a dynamoelectric machine operating at zero power factor, lagging, the magnetomotive force in the magnetic circuit which produces cross flux between adjacent teeth of increasing magnitude between root and tip of each tooth, due to currents in slot conductors, is represented in the electric circuit by corresponding voltages which produce currents in resistors 52 between corresponding portions of adjacent series circuits. These voltages may be supplied from suitable batteries or, as shown, from generator 25 through adjustable voltage transformers I I8, one for each group of phototubes.

Each transformer II8 comprises secondary windings H9 to I22 which are separately wound to prevent leakage currents therebetween. Each winding I I9 to I22 is connected across the terminals of a polarity reversing switch II3 through a suitable half wave rectifier I I4. The switches I I3 may be closed to the left or to the right to connect the secondary windings I I9 to I22 across the terminals of corresponding shorting switches 53. Shorting switches 53 are opened and switch I23 closed to connect transformer II8 with generator 25. I

For Zero power factor lagging analysis, all of the shorting switches 53 are opened. The windings H9 and I20 are connected across the terminal of corresponding shorting switches 53 by means comprising associated reversing switches I I3 which are closed to the right so that the currents supplied by these windings flow in the same direction between circuits, from the first series circuit to the second, and from the second series circuit to the third. The windings I2I and I22 are also connected by their associated reversing switches I I3 which are closed to the left so that currents therefrom flow in the same direction between series circuits from the fourth to the fifth series circuits and from the fifth to the sixthv aeoaess .2

through zerooppositewthe center of theipole' With ia. positive .quarterwave assumed on the left half and a negativequarter wave on the right half of the pole pitch portion of the -core, thecenterof the pole pitch portion of the core being between teeth II and I2.: Therefore, secondary' windings IIB to I221varyin relative ampere-turns so-that the values of the voltages thereof will-appear as a sine wave of voltage distributed across the circuit representing the pole-pitch portion-as the-sine wave of magnetomotive force 1 inthe armature slots.

Means comprising the adjustable voltage tap of the'primary winding'of -each transformer H8 provide simultaneous adjustment of the voltages of the secondary windings II9'-to I 22 of one group independently of the voltages of the other groups. I

The currentin the ar-mature windings also 1 produces different magnetomotive forces across the air gap portions extending between the different teeth and the pole' piece.

tional voltage source in each'series circuit, which source "may comprise a-battery,r or; asshown, air adjustable voltage transformer I24; Transformer-I24 has an adjustalole tap primary wind-' 7 ing which may i be connected to' generator '25 i by means of a switch 64. Transformer 924 has adjustable tap, separately wound; secondary windings I25 to-l3ll, eachof which is connected across a shorting switchthrough a rectifier'fl:

Shorting-switches-JH, 5|, 6!, H, 8i; and iii,

shownclosed,are opened and transformer switch" 64 is closed so that the voltages of windings I25 to 'l3fl'appear across the terminal of-shorting switches 5i, SI; 4|, H,- 8I,'and 9!, respectively. The adjustable voltage tap ofgtheprimary winding of transformer I24 provides means for simultaneously varying the amplitude of the voltages of windings I25 to I30. These secondary windings I25 to I3Il-are independentlyadjusted so that the relativemagnitudes-of their voltages will--be distributed-"as-the inverted half of a" sine wave across thepole pitch to correspond to'the sine wave of magnetomotiveforces which they --represent. The' direction and magnitude of these voltages aresuch that they add 'to the value-of the-voltage-from"winding '27-, so that the sum of such voltages represent corresponding resultant magnetomotive forces across the arma ture' and pole piece due to currents in both armatureandfield windings.

The total fieldmagnetomotive force required to drive the flux crossing the air gap through the armature teeth andpole-piece for-zero power factor, lagging operation of the dynamoelectric machine is represented by the voltages supplied from transformers 26 and I3I, the latter connected to generator 25 through a switch I34.

Secondary windings I32 and I33 of transformer I3I are eachconnected through a half wave rectifier I M to the terminals of-shorting switches 63 and 93 which are-opened-and switch I3 2 is closed for adding a unidirectional voltage -be-- tween circuit conductor -42 and resistor 62 and At zero-power factor lagging, thearmature magnetomotive' force is sinusoidally distributed across the-pole between I conductor A2 ti'and resistor 92 I to supply additional". current through. resistors Bil ;and:.;92

in the samedirection therethrough: as current v supplied from winding 21.

Readings of the values of the currents andvoltages across the. resistance elements :of the electric circuit, indicate proportionate values; of

fluxes in and .magnetomotive forces. acrosspcore;

responding reluctance elements in the magneticcircuit'ior zero powerx factor, lagging, operating condition of the dynamo-electric machine. The distribution of such: values irepresents .the acorresponding distributionzin the magnetic -circuits.

For-other power factor conditions of operation:

of the dynamoelectriclmachine, the saturation conditions of the magnetic circuitcan be analyzed-.1

by the-electric analogue circuit shown iniFig; 1,?

takinginto considerati'onathe. changes inj-thet rents-in the armature windings. The voltages in the electric circuit would bechanged-to :repremagnetic circuit due to the'changes in the ;cur.-:.-

sent the change inmagnetomotive-forces .in'the magnetic circuit. The sine wave of 'magnetomotive force distribution is transposed somthatxz the zero value of magnetomotive force is: moved 3' to the left or-to the right one or' more tooth'ipitch portions according to the power factor. condie tion of operation.

Such transposition of the-sine wave vof imag netomotive-force may be considered as relative displacement 'of the --pole'--'with:respect- .to. the

armature.

The portions of the pole willthenbe adjacent different armature teeth. Theiselector switch 4i providesmeans for reconnecting-the portions of the series-circuits representing the armature teeth with the corresponding portionsm of the electric circuit representing the portion of the pole then adjacent the teeth; Thus, movingselector switch one'tapposition to'the rig-ht,---

representing'movement of he armature one tooth pitch-tothe-right of the pole one tooth pitch to the left for'another lagging power-factor condition, connects phototube 5i3 -with--winding' I26 and resistor 50;- phototube 48- withresistor 30 phototube 38 with resistor I0; phototube -fifi with l winding I21 and resistor til:- phototube 'la with" winding I28 and resistor-9il; and phototube S8 with' windi11g--i25- andfresistor- 69. Reversingswitches H3 between series circuits 'five' and si-r are reversed, beingmoved from the position shown, closed to the left, the right. 3

Movement of the selector switch, through all positions, to the extreme-right; effeetivelymoves toa closed position-to the pole to the left from the initial zero power factor lagging position; through unity power factor position, to 'zero power factor leading position. If the dy-narnzo'ele'ctric machine is a'gen erat'or, its field must! be considered as rotating counterclockwise; if the dynam-oe'lectric machine is a motor, its field. rnustbe co-nsideredflas rotating clockwise; or fro'nrzero power f'actor 'lagging po.

sition to; unity power factor position,fforclockwise rotatio-n oi therotor; the rotor pole is moved a in the-direction of rotation if the i dynamoelem' tr'ic machine is ;a generator, and the rotor pole is moved the aopposite :direction; if

the-dynamo-r electric machineis a motor.

For a power factornearuni-"ty,-- theselect-or i switch is moved tothe fourth'contact position, counting from the left, and the reversing switch-es- II3 are all closed to the right so that the direc- .tion of flow of current-in resistors 52 is to the left between circuits, from the sixth to the first In Fig. is illustrated the use of a resistor I36,

in lieu of a shorting switch 53', connected in series with adjustable resistor 52 between phototubes of adjacent series circuits. Resistors I36 are connected across the secondary windings M9 to I22 through reversing switches II3, to supply voltages in the circuit, when switch I 23 is closed, to represent cross flux between adjacent teeth. A capacitor I35 may be inserted across each secondary winding and associated rectifier H4 for smoothing out the rectified wave.

Similarly, resistors I36 shunt secondary windings I25 to I30, I32 and I33 in lieu of shorting switches GI, 5I, 4|, II, 8|, 3|, 63 and 93, respectively. A capacitor I35 may be connected across each winding I25 and I33, I32 and I33.

Although but two embodiments of the invention have been shown and described, it will be apparent to those skilled in the art that the electric analogue circuit is applicable to other problems than the magnetic circuit of a dynamoelectric machine, and that various changes and modifications may be made to the embodiments without departing from the spirit of the invention or from the scope of the appended claims.

It is claimed and desired to secure by Letters Patent:

1. A magnetic saturation analyzer for the magnetic circuit of a salient pole dynamoelectric machine for determining saturation characteristics thereof, said analyzer consisting of a mesh electric circuit comprising a plurality of series circuits connected in parallel to a source of direct current, each said series circuit comprising a linear resistance element, a plurality of nonlinear resistance elements having values proportional to the reluctances of corresponding portions of said magnetic circuit to the flow of through flux, and another linear resistance element cross connected between .a nonlinear resistance element of one series circuit and a corresponding nonlinear resistance element of an adjacentseries circuit, said cross connected element having a value proportional to the reluctance of a corresponding portion of said magnetic circuit to the flow of cross flux.

2. A magnetic saturation analyzer for the magnetic circuit of a salient pole dynam-oelectric machine for determining saturation characteristic thereof, said analyzer comprising linear and nonlinear resistance elements interconnected to form an electric mesh circuit substantially the equivalent of the magnetic circuit of said machine, said mesh circuit comprising a first group of nonlinear resistance elements having a com-- mon terminal, a cross circuit comprising a first linear resistance element in series with a first source of unidirectional voltage connected between adjacent said nonlinear resistance elem-ents of said first group, a second group of nonlinear resistance elements of which each is connected in series with a nonlinear resistance element of said first group, a group of linear resistance elements of which each is connected in series with a nonlinear resistance element of said second group, a second source of unidirectional voltage connected in series between one of said linear resistance elements of said group of linear resistance elements and one of said nonlinear resistance elements of said second group, a third source of unidirectional voltage connected across said groups of resistance elements, mean for varying the values of said resistance elements and said voltages, and means for measuring the current in any given resistance element in said mesh circuit which current is indicative of the fiux in the corresponding portion of the magnetic circuit.

3. A magnetic saturation analyzer for determining the magnetic fiux in the components of a magnetic circuit, said analyzer comprising an electric circuit including a plurality of photo- 'tubes, means for illuminating said phototubes, means for adjusting the illumination of said phototubes for obtaining a predetermined voltampere characteristic representing the reluctance characteristic of a corresponding portion of said magnetic circuit, a plurality of series circuits connected in parallel across a source of unidirectional voltage, each said series circuit comprising one of said phototubes, a cross circuit comprising a variable linear resistor and a second source of variable unidirectional voltage connected between phototubes of adjacent said series circuits, means for adjusting said resistor to represent the linear reluctance of another portion of said magnetic circuit opposed to the flow of cross flux, and means for adjusting said voltages for representing magnetomotive forces in said magnetic circuit. 7

4. A magnetic saturation analyzer for determining the magnetic flux in the components of a magnetic circuit, said analyzer comprising an electric circuit including a plurality of groups of phototubes and a group of variable resistors, means for illuminating said phototubes, means for simultaneously varying the illumination of one said group independently of the other said groups for representing the nonlinear reluctances of parallel portions of said magnetic circuit, a plurality of series circuits connected in parallel to a source of unidirectional voltage, each said series circuit comprising corresponding phototubes of each said group connected in series with each other and with one of said variable resistors, and another source of variable unidirectional voltage connected between one of said resistors and the adjacent connected said phototube, means for adjusting each said resistor to represent other portions of said magnetic circuit, and means for adjusting said voltages for representing magnetomotive forces in said magnetic circuit.

5. -A magnetic saturation analyzer for determining the saturation characteristics of a magnetic circuit of a dynamoelectric machine having a core provided with teeth and a salient pole provided with tips, said analyzer comprising a source of unidirectional voltage to represent the magnetomotive force across the magnetic circuit, a plurality of circuits, each said circuit comprising a plurality of series connected nonlinear resistance elements having values representing the reluctance of portions of a core tooth from the root to the tip thereof, a linear resistance element in series with said nonlinear resistance elements dimensioned to represent the reluctance 6.,An electric analogue. computer for solving.

1 single valued functions ofnonlinear parameters, said-computer comprisingan electric circuit including apluralityof, phototubes connected in :groups,-means for illuminating said phototubes,

means for simultaneously varying the illumina-,

tion of all said phototubes, means. for simultaneously varying :the illumination of. the photo- 1 tubes of. oneof said groups independently of. the .illumination of the other saidphototubes, means for varying. the illumination of each phototube independently, of the illumination of the other ,said phototubes, a; plurality .of* series circuits connected in parallel to afirst source of variable voltage, each said seriescircuit comprising a -phototube' of.-eachsaid group, said electric circuit also comprising a plurality of: adjustable resistors, a plurality ofblocking rectifiers and a pluralityof other sources of Variable voltages, each of said resistors connected through one of said rectifier-s and ne-ofsaid other sources of voltages between adjacentsaid phototubes of one of said groups, and means-for adjusting said resistors, means for varying said voltages;-whereby .the values of the resistances and voltagesin said electric circuit correspond to. the values of the components of. the nonlinear parameters.

'7. A magnetic saturation analyzer for the magnetic circuit of a salient pole dynamoelectric .machine-for determining saturation characteristicszcthereof said analyzer comprising linear and nonlinear; resistance, elements dimensioned and iinterconnectedqto form anelectricmesh circuit substantially the equivalent of the magnetic. circuit of saidmachine, said mesh circuit comprisinga=plurality of groups of similarly connected linear and.-nonlinear resistance elements and sources "ofunid-irectional voltage, said nonlinear resistance elements of. a first said group connee-ted toa common terminal, adjacent said nonlinear resistance elements-of said first group connected'tinparallel through one of said linear resistance elements of said first group, switch .meansior connectingisaidone of said linear resistance elements ofsaid, first group in series with one of said-sources ofunidirectional voltage; eachrcorresponding said nonlinear resistance elementaofsucceedingsaid groups connected in .serieswitheach other and the corresponding said nonlinear resistance element of said first group; .=-a group of additional linear resistance elements of which each is connected in series with corresponding series connected nonlinear resistance elements, a group-of additional sources of unidirectional voltage and switch means for conriectingone of saidadditional: sources of voltage in series between one of said additional linear resistanceelements and said corresponding series .connectednonlinear resistance. elements, a main source otunidirectional voltage connected across said series. connected resistance elements and "said additional source ofunidirectional voltage. -means-iorsimultaneously varying the values of the voltages of all said groups, means for simul- .taneously-"varying the values of the voltages of :onesald; group independently of .the values. of

1 the voltages of the other-said groups;.;and means for varying the value of said resistance elements; whereby. the saturation characteristics oirsaid dynamoelectrici machine ::.may :be analyzediifor open circuit and. poweria'ctor conditions.

-8.--A magnetic saturation analyzerx-fortdetermining the .fiux inthe: components; of armagnetic circuit, said analyzer comprising .anelectric circuit including .a. plurality.:of series. circuits connected in parallel to a source .of:unidirectional voltage, each said. series circuit .comprising a phototube, each-adjacentpairrof .phototubes of adjacent said series-circuits, :havinganother source. of" unidirectional voltage connected therebetween; "means. for simultaneously varying :the valuesofsaid other voltagesinia sine wave space distribution to'correspond to; the .sine wavedistributionof ampere-turnssin "said magnetic circuit.

9. Anv electric analogue computer for solving single valued nonlinear parameters; said; computer comprising an electric circuit including a source of electric'current,-a phototuba a resistance element and an electric :m'eterflsaid phototube being. connected in parallel with said resistance element across said source, s'aidelement having the value required for producing one of said nonlinear parameters,- and means connecting said meter-in said circuit-iormeasur ingan electrical characteristic of said circuit.

10; A magnetic saturation analyzer fordetermininglthe flux in the components ofa magnetic circuit, said analyzer comprising an electric circuit including a plurality ofseries circuits connected in parallel to a source of unidirectional voltage, each said seriescircuit comprising 1 a nonlinear resistance element, a-linear resistance element and another source of unidirectional voltage connected in series with said resistance elements, and means for simultaneously varying the values of said other Voltages in a-sine wave space distribution to correspond to the sine wave distribution of ampere turns in said magnetic circuit. 11. A magnetic saturation analyzer for the magnetic circuit of a salient pole dynamoelectric machinefor determining saturation characteristics thereofisaid analyzer comprising an electriccircuit including linear resistance elements of values representing the linear reluctances of portions'of the'air gap in said magnetic circuit, nonlinear resistance elements of values representing the nonlinear reluctances of portions of the magnetic -mater1al in said magnetic circuit, each said non linear resistance element including a phototube connected in parallel with an adjustable resistor for changing the" volt-ampere characteristic of the nonlinear'resistanceelement, asource of electromotive force of value representing the magnetomotive force impressed on said magnetic circuit, said resistance elements connected in series circuits across said source of electromotive force to representsaid magnetic material and said air gap disposed inseries across said source ofv magnetomotive force, an electric meter, and means connecting said meter in said electric circuit for measuring the currents insaid electric circuit which represent corresponding magnetic fluxes in said magnetic circuit.

STERLING BECKWITH. ELDO C; KOENIG.

(References on; following page) 13 REFERENCES CITED The following references are of record in the file of this patent:

UNITED STATES PATENTS 14 OTHER REFERENCES Hydraulic Analysis of Water Distribution Systems by Means of an Electric Network Analyzer, by T. R. Camp and H. L. Hazen; M. I. T.

5 Publication No. 110, June 1935.

RCA Receiving Tube Manual; Tube Dept, Radio Corp. of America; 1950; page 267; circuit No. 16-4. 

